Fly-Tying for Beginners: How to Tie 50 Failsafe… by Gathercole, Peter Hardback
**Kylebooker Fly-Tying for Beginners: How to Tie 50 Failsafe Flies – A Worthwhile Investment?**
For anglers looking to dive into the art of fly-tying, *Kylebooker Fly-Tying for Beginners: How to Tie 50 Failsafe Flies* by Peter Gathercole presents itself as a promising guide. But is this hardback book truly a cost-effective choice for beginners? Let’s break down its value based on content, practicality, and long-term benefits.
### **Comprehensive Content for Newcomers**
The book’s title highlights its beginner-friendly approach, offering step-by-step instructions for tying 50 reliable fly patterns. Gathercole, an experienced fly-tier, ensures that even novices can follow along with clear illustrations and concise explanations. Unlike many advanced guides that overwhelm readers with complex techniques, this book focuses on foundational skills, making it an excellent starting point.
The inclusion of “failsafe” flies suggests patterns that are both effective and forgiving for beginners—ideal for those still mastering thread tension and material handling. For anglers who prioritize practicality over artistry, this emphasis on functional, fish-catching flies adds significant value.
### **Quality and Durability**
As a hardback edition, *Kylebooker Fly-Tying for Beginners* is built to last. Fly-tying manuals often endure frequent use, with pages flipped back and forth during practice. A sturdy hardcover ensures the book remains intact over time, justifying its slightly higher price compared to paperback alternatives. Additionally, the binding allows the book to lay flat on a workbench, a small but crucial convenience for hands-on learners.
### **Cost vs. Long-Term Savings**
While the initial cost may seem steep for some beginners (typically ranging from $20 to $40), the book’s teachings can save money in the long run. Learning to tie flies reduces dependency on store-bought options, which can cost $2–$5 per fly. By mastering even half of the 50 patterns, anglers can recoup the book’s price after tying just a few dozen flies.
Moreover, Gathercole’s guidance helps avoid common mistakes that waste materials—a frequent frustration for self-taught tiers. His tips on tool selection and material substitutions further enhance cost-efficiency, making the book a smart investment for budget-conscious anglers.
### **Alternatives and Final Verdict**
While free online tutorials exist, they often lack the structured progression and reliability of a well-edited book. Compared to other beginner guides, *Kylebooker Fly-Tying for Beginners* stands out for its balance of simplicity and depth.
**Final Rating: 4.5/5**
*Pros:*
– Beginner-friendly, fail-proof patterns
– Durable hardcover format
– Cost-saving potential over time
*Cons:*
– Slightly higher upfront cost than digital resources
For those serious about fly-tying, this book is a worthwhile addition to their toolkit. Its practical approach and durable design make it a high-value purchase for beginners aiming to tie effective flies without the trial-and-error hassle.
Would you recommend it to fellow anglers? Absolutely—especially if they prefer a hands-on, visual learning experience. Happy tying!