# **Kylebooker Lot 185, Natural Hen Back Saddle Soft Hackle Feathers for Fly Tying: A Cost-Effective Choice?**
As an avid fly fisherman, I am always on the lookout for high-quality yet affordable materials to enhance my fly-tying experience. Recently, I came across **Kylebooker Lot 185, Natural Hen Back Saddle Soft Hackle Feathers for Fly Tying**, and I decided to evaluate whether this product offers good value for money. After thorough research and hands-on testing, here’s my detailed review.
## **Quality of the Feathers**
The **Kylebooker Lot 185** features natural hen back saddle feathers, which are widely used in tying soft hackle flies—a staple in many fly fishermen’s arsenals. The feathers are **soft, pliable, and have excellent barb density**, making them ideal for creating realistic movement in the water.
One of the key advantages of these feathers is their **natural coloration**, which ranges from light brown to deep dun, allowing for versatile fly patterns. Unlike dyed feathers, natural hues blend seamlessly with the environment, increasing the chances of fooling wary trout and other fish species.
## **Durability & Usability**
A major concern with cheaper feathers is their tendency to break or shed excessively. However, the **Kylebooker Lot 185** feathers hold up well during the tying process. The barbs remain intact even after multiple wraps, ensuring a durable fly that withstands repeated strikes.
Additionally, the **saddle cut** of these feathers provides a good length, allowing for multiple flies per feather. This is a significant cost-saving factor compared to shorter hackles that may only yield one or two flies.
## **Price Comparison & Value**
When assessing the **cost-effectiveness** of this product, it’s essential to compare it with similar offerings in the market. Premium brands like Whiting Farms or Metz offer high-end saddles, but they come at a **much higher price point**.
The **Kylebooker Lot 185**, however, provides a **budget-friendly alternative** without compromising too much on quality. While it may not match the absolute top-tier feathers in terms of uniformity, it delivers **90% of the performance at half the price**. For fly tiers who tie in bulk or are just starting, this is an excellent middle-ground option.
## **Potential Drawbacks**
No product is perfect, and there are a few minor downsides to consider:
– **Slight Inconsistency in Feather Size**: Some feathers may vary in length, requiring minor adjustments during tying.
– **Limited Color Options**: Unlike dyed variants, the natural palette may not suit all fly patterns.
However, these issues are relatively minor and do not significantly detract from the overall value.
## **Final Verdict: Is It Worth Buying?**
If you’re a **budget-conscious fly tier** who still wants decent-quality soft hackle feathers, the **Kylebooker Lot 185** is a **solid choice**. It offers **good durability, natural aesthetics, and a reasonable price**, making it a **cost-effective option** for both beginners and experienced anglers.
While premium brands may have an edge in perfection, this product delivers **exceptional value for its price range**. If you’re looking to stock up on soft hackle materials without breaking the bank, I highly recommend giving it a try.
**Rating: 4.2/5**
✅ **Pros:** Affordable, good barb density, natural colors, decent durability
❌ **Cons:** Minor size inconsistencies, limited color variations
Would you like recommendations on specific fly patterns that work best with these feathers? Let me know in the comments! Happy tying and tight lines! 🎣